Some Israel Impressions – Harry & Carter

We loved Israel; the positive energy, range of cultures and religions, beautiful nature ranging from arid desert to mountain snow and the grinding tense reality of its existence. Highlights included visiting with our friend Noam, a lifelong Israeli who happens to be an atheist with a Zen/carpe dieme outlook and chatting over drinks with Mowis, our Christian innkeeper who was warm and welcoming but had a more fatalistic outlook.

Below are some of our impressions.

* Entering Israel via the southern border from Jordan…A big transition in just a couple of hours from waking in a Bedouin tent in Jordan’s Wadi Rum desert to arriving in Eilat, the ‘Atlantic City’ resort town of Israel. Surrounded by bikinis instead of burqas and swimming in the beautiful Red Sea protected by machine gun-toting patrol boats just beyond the lifeguard buoys while looking out at Jordan and Egypt. Contrasting the Israel shorelines uniquely filled with windsurfers, jet skis, party boats and kite boarders to the desolate Jordanian shores. The day we leave, two missiles fired from Gaza aimed at Eilat, land in an unoccupied area of the city.

* Taking the bus through the desert north of Eilat and on to the Jerusalem outskirts…where the bus is boarded by two soldiers in bullet proof vests holding machine guns who walk the length of the vehicle looking into the eyes of each passenger before jumping off.

* Hearing sirens for a full two minutes in a newer part of Jerusalem to mark the start of Veterans’ Day and watching everyone stand still, cars and buses stop while their drivers stand outside their vehicles in remembrance of soldiers who died. Very moving. The next day in the Old City during the two minute siren marking the end of the holiday half the crowd continue walking and driving- Arab residents who chose not to recognize the event.

* Seeing jubilant Independence Day celebrations filling the streets with revelers wrapped in the Israeli flag, spraying each other with foam and singing patriotic songs until 2am.

* Learning about rational gun laws (mental health exams, yearly mandatory training classes, annual limit on the number of bullets available for purchase per person) while simultaneously reading about the embarrassment in the U.S. Congress that voted to maintain our nonsensical, self-sabotaging rules.

* Being starved on Saturday afternoon and realizing it’s the Sabbath and nothing is open…

* Walking through the ancient alleys of the coastal city of Akko and seeing a plaque on a wall thanking the Harry and Jeanette Weinberg Foundation of Baltimore for supporting the construction of a child care center.

* Seeing orthodox Jews with their distinct dress throughout Jerusalem..but rarely in liberal Tel Aviv with its 24 hour party reputation and where we also found ourselves sitting on “Gay Beach” with overt public displays of affection.

* Feeling the energy in Mahane Yehuda Market (think an ancient Lexington Market) with roasting nuts, baking pita, squeezing juices. Seeing people pop olives or a handful of nuts right into their mouths from piles of product. Watching people push in front of any sort of queue. Eating excessively sweet chocolate rugelach off huge trays hot from the oven.

* Standing on Mt. Bental in the Golan Heights amid the ruins of Syrian fortifications and looking into the distance at Damascus and seeing black smoke rising…while two Israeli fighter jets fly loops overhead parallel to the border setting off sonic booms. Watching Arab Israeli teens on a field trip there jamming music on their iPhones and posing for cameras ignoring their teachers’ history lesson while a separate group of elderly Israelis pick up trash at the site while listening to their guide.

* Spending days walking through the marvel that is the old city of Jerusalem while reading ‘O Jerusalem!’ which describes in detail the war of independence, neighborhood by neighborhood. Imagining weapons caches entering the city piece by piece under women and children’s clothing. Exiting the Damascus gate one day and walking into a Palestinian protest monitored by Israeli police and feeling the tension in the air.

* Driving alongside the massive grey concrete walls separating Jerusalem from the West Bank. Controversial walls debated heavily by Israelis in that they established a boundary and ended economic hopes for many Palestinians who worked in Jerusalem, but also were 100% effective in stopping suicide bombers.

* Walking through Jerusalem and Tel Aviv and coming across memorials where bombs had gone off during the intifadas.

* Seeing young male and female soldiers going home on the weekend to visit their families either in or out of uniform, but always carrying their machine guns. Mandatory service is from age 18 and runs for 3 years for men, 2 for women.

* Traveling to a Druze village in the northern tip of the country under the shadow and snow of Mt. Hebron and standing at the border fence with Syria at ‘Shouting Hill’ where relatives used to communicate back and forth across the border with via megaphones before cellphones and Skype. That night watching the movie ‘The Syrian Bride’ on YouTube, an accessible movie that highlights the issues in this town.

* Learning of the fierce internal debate the country has over orthodox who are exempt from military service and who are paid a stipend to study Torah only (no history, literature, comparative religions, etc.) full time. This scenario was established when there were only a few hundred people applying. Those numbers have ballooned to a significant number. (We heard it was up to 10% of the population.) The participants argue that it is their prayers that keep bombs from falling on Israel. This argument is not well received by taxpayers who are pushing to end the program or, at least, enforce some other civic duty instead of military service.

* Seeing the complicated nature of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (where Christ may have died, been anointed and buried) and its numerous denominations sharing space including Ethiopians who live on the roof and cannot leave (even for 10 minutes) or else lose their claim.

* Walking alone for 20 minutes in the pitch black, 100 feet underground sloshing in knee-deep water through a shoulder-width, low roofed, ancient stone water tunnel hoping the $10 Home Depot headlamp does not give out.

* Floating, literally, ON the Dead Sea. It is actually hard to stand up as the water pulls your legs to the surface.

* Standing on the edge of the Sea of Galilee surrounded by tacky, 1970’s construction, dirty water and restricted shore access and having trouble picturing what it must have looked like ‘back then’.

* Standing on a hilltop in Haifa looking down on the beautiful, immaculate Baha’i temple and out at the ocean. ..and learning that night that the Israel Defense Force had shot down a Hezbollah drone offshore in the same area, the same day.

– Harry & Carter

I felt very comfortable in Israel throughout the entire trip and thought often of the many Jewish friends I have had growing up in the United States and various religious ceremonies I have attended in their temples.

I wish I had visited Israel as a teenager. Then, the last thirty years of reading about the country’s role in Middle East events in the New York Times would have had a more personal impact and I would have been able to compare notes with my Jewish friends returning from their trips to Israel.

-Harry

I’m embarrassed to admit it but ever since my dad tried to explain to me the conflict over Israel when I was 13, I sort of put it into my mental pile of unexplainable things- like computer code, car repair, understanding why Japanese tourists take so many pictures, electricity. Right before arrival, I felt downright euphoric to finally see what all the hubbub and my lifetime’s worth of front page articles was all about. From our travels, it was the first time I felt like we were home and didn’t have to say we were from Canada… We felt very safe on the streets as there is little crime. We drove home from a friend’s house after midnight and saw a mom walking her sleepless child through a park and many regular folks enjoying the outside. We thought we’d be 10 days and stayed over 3 weeks. Next time we’ll go into the West Bank, Bethlehem, Ramallah. One last thing, the food, no one told me about the extraordinary food based on vegetables, olives, nuts, dried fruits and exquisite baked goods.

-Carter

4 responses to “Some Israel Impressions – Harry & Carter

  1. I love these updates!! One colorful vignette after another. Sounds like it was an incredible stop!

  2. I loved your impressions on Israel. In a short blog you described the variations you can see, experience and feel in Israel.

    The full trip is something incredible that a sane family might take it on, but it turns out to be possible and rich in experience.

    I am sure your views of the world will be totally different from the day you started and the youngsters will start life with much more than the 6 months schooling they missed.

    How did you hit on such an incredible idea?
    Zvi Ever
    Haifa, Israel
    zviever@alum.mit.edu

  3. A Westerner in the West Bank

    Hi, I came across your blog from Haaretz and I’ve got to say I’m really disappointed. You obviously had an enjoyable holiday, but it’s such a shame that from your blog it seems you were not shown the reality of the situation in Israel and Palestine. I wonder if you even know that when you were in East Jerusalem you were in fact in Palestine? Palestine that it is internationally acknowledged by the UN and international law that Israel has illegally occupied and annexed with the separation barrier. I wonder if you noticed the state of apartheid that exists in the West Bank, where illegal Israeli settlers live under different laws to Palestinians in their homeland – there are literally roads for Israelis that Palestinians are not allowed to use. In Palestine.

    Next time you definitely should visit the West Bank, and meet Palestinians. Because you can very quickly realise that the only danger in Palestine and Israel is from the Israelis. The guns are sported by IDF and Israelis alone – Palestinian citizens are not allowed to be armed – and it is Palestinians who have been and continue to be massacred and oppressed daily. I recommend you take a look at a few Palestinian news sources, or Al Jazeera (a very reputable and reliable news agency) to get an idea of some of the atrocities Israelis commit against Palestinians each and every day – http://english.pnn.ps/index.php http://www.aljazeera.com/Services/Search/?q=palestine

    There is much in your blog that I could challenge as inaccurate and obviously derived from an incorrect Israeli propaganda perspective, but 1 simple comment you make that is particularly important to challenge I believe is your comment on Israeli “independence day”. Do you know that Israeli independence day marks the day that Israel committed atrocious acts of war, by instigating one of its largest individual successes in ethnically cleansing Palestine of its people? At the end of the 1948 war, which Palestinians celebrate as Nakba (the catastrophe) and Israelis as their “independence day” (independence from what I do not know), over 700,000 Palestinians were expelled from their homes by Israel and became refugees. There are now, 65 years later, over 5 million Palestinian refugees. Israel does not permit any refugee their legal Right to Return to their homes, and has not compensated a single individual.

    I think it is important to raise these issues because a family like yourselves that has visited only Israel (other than when you were in Palestine and did not know it – such as East Jerusalem) has obviously been presented with this Israeli propaganda. There are many Israelis who support the Palestinian cause – it’s a shame you did not seem to get the opportunity to meet any of them, and an even greater shame that you did not get to know some of the extremely welcoming and generous Palestinians who live under constant oppression and occupation by Israel, yet continue with such strength of will. I’m writing a blog whilst living in Palestine, and I’d really like to share some of my insights and experiences with you, as you did not manage to have the same, and perhaps next time you can experience these for yourself – http://www.whatgemmathinks.wordpress.com/

    I hope that you visit Palestine and share your experiences with people, to combat the damagingly inaccurate perceptions people in the Western World have of Palestine (as you have substantiated in this blog), and the misinformation our media presents us with. Awareness-raising is very important to mobilise society into realising the problems others face – the persistent and inhumane human rights violations Palestinians suffer daily need to be stopped, and we need to lobby our governments to act in supporting Palestinians’ cause. I hope that you will join me in this in the future.

    • Dear “Westerner in the West Bank”,

      Thank you for taking the time to write us back in April. My apologies for the delay in this note, but we were moving too quickly on the road to be able to sit down and respond thoughtfully and respect the time you put into your communication. I am not näive enough to believe that we learned everything on this trip and your note was a perfect reminder. When looking at an iceberg, you see only 10% of the ice – the other 90% is invisible under the water. On our trip, I feel that we saw only that 10% in the countries we went to. I understand that this was true as well with Israel/Palestine (and especially so as we saw only 10% of the Israeli side). Believe me when I say that we wanted to see Palestine. However, when planning the trip, we didn’t know how to begin. So, who did we ask for ideas? Our Jewish friends from back home. The Palestinian side seemed like a great unknown and we weren’t prepared to visit without knowing anyone there or anyone who had visited before. We therefore ended up simply traveling along the Israeli side. We were only aware that we were in Palestine in East Jerusalem after reading up on the situation thereafter.

      Even before we read your note or even came to Israel, we realized the horrible crisis that was occurring throughout this region. Before and after the trip each of us has read books on the situation and we’ve tried to keep up on the different events that make it into the western media. If our blog sounds heavily biased it was because we wrote what we saw, and we only saw the Israeli side. Before we left we all agreed that there still lay a major gap in our knowledge. Next time we visit we would love to see both sides, and if you could point us in the right direction that would be much appreciated. Are there certain neighborhoods or cities you would suggest? Do you know any websites or guides that could help us make a better framework for our next trip? Anything would be great. I’ve looked at your own blog a couple times, but will no doubt delve in further in the future. Finally, could you email me three books you think our whole family should read to give us a better understanding of the conflict (hgbrigham@gmail.com)? I’m sure we’ll recommend them to our friends as well. We have only hit the tip of the iceberg, but are very interested in learning more; we will return to Palestine. I have the advantage of being just 16 years old and have time to return to the Middle East many times. Thank you again for taking the time to write us and for being so direct. Can I forward your note to some of our friends (without your email address)? I think it’s very informative and quite a reality check for more than just my family.

      Thanks again,

      Greer

      P.S. What do you think will come of the coming peace talks? The series of failures in the past does not promote too much optimism, but maybe some issues will be addressed.

Leave a reply to hdbrigham Cancel reply